Heraldnet.com
MONDAY, NOVEMBER 9, 2009 12:08 pm
ADVERTISEMENT

LocalNorthwestNation & WorldPoliticsSpecial ReportsPhotosColumnistsMultimedia 
Blog
Jerry Cornfield
House Speaker Pelosi visits Seattle today
Your town news
Julie Muhlstein
Columnist Julie Muhlstein's take on life in Snohomish County.
•Latest: Journalist John Hockenberry aims for good and bad
Kristi O'Harran
Columnist Kristi O'Harran writes about people in Snohomish County.
•Latest: Digging into JFK’s death remains a lifelong passion
Latest gallery

Memorial for Timothy Brenton
November 6. 2009 (17 photos)
[More Herald photos]
 
WEEK IN REVIEW
Sunday
Six injured, three critically, in wreck near Ma...
Gay marriage issue can wait, say Referendum 71 ...
Glacier Peak freshman overcomes jitters to win ...
Saturday
More snow expected at mountain passes
Suspect identified in Seattle police killing
Thousands honor slain Seattle police officer Ti...
Friday


Officer Timothy Brenton. Gone, but not forgotten
Person sought in officer's killing is shot in head
Thousands to pay respects to slain Seattle poli...
Thursday


Tale of 1916 Everett Massacre retold in style o...
Reservist survived Iraq but not his return to c...
Swine flu suspected in infant’s death
Wednesday


‘Everything but marriage' law close to vi...
Library levy winning by 51% to 49%
Incumbents looking strong in Snohomish County C...
Tuesday


Delayed financial aid forcing college students ...
Slaying of officer reminds police of dangers of...
Edmonds turns over firefighting duties to Fire ...
Monday


Question isn't 'if' but 'how bad' for floods
Slain Seattle Police officer lived in Marysville
Rubatino Refuse allows recycling of food scraps...
 

ADVERTISEMENT

Local News   Print This Article  Email This Page  Subscribe Now! facebook digg reddit del.icio.us fark stumble

 
ADVERTISEMENT

 
 
CONTACT THE HERALD
Robert Frank, City Editor
frank@heraldnet.com
 
Published: Friday, June 13, 2008

Monroe mother defends son kicked out of Marines

MONROE -- While the U.S. Marine Corps is discharging her son, a mother's love defines a life beyond the military.

"A moment of using bad judgment does not portray the true character or integrity of my son David," David Motari's mother said in a statement Thursday. "It does not show that when he was home on leave, the last thing he would do was buy soft dog food for our aging dog 'Bear.' "

The 17-second video showing Lance Cpl. David Motari throwing a puppy into a gully doesn't change the 22-year-old's service in combat for his county, the family said.

"It does not show the kind and gentle heart of a young man who served his country for 3½ years of his life," the family said. "Nor does it show the battles he fought in Afghanistan or Iraq; that he fought for the freedom of the people of Afghanistan, Iraq and the United States of America!"

The Herald is not naming Motari's mother out of concern for the family's safety.

Motari is being kicked out of the service after the Marine Corps wrapped up a three-month investigation of the circumstances surrounding the video. The Marine Corps released a statement Wednesday, formally deploring Motari's conduct.

"This was a very detailed, very thorough investigation that went through the entire chain of command," said Maj. Chris Perrine of Marine Corps Base Hawaii, where Motari's unit was stationed.

Perrine said privacy laws prohibited him from saying whether Motari has been dishonorably discharged. He did say that Motari is leaving before his service contract ends on Dec. 5, and that he will not be allowed to re-enlist with the Marine Corps.

Motari was a member of the 1st Battalion, 3rd Marines. The unit repeatedly engaged the enemy in the sere landscape of Afghanistan as part of Operation Mountain Lion. That was the second-largest U.S. military combat operation in Afghanistan since the war began.

In Iraq, the Marines of Charlie Company saw action near the village of Haqlaniyah, where they regularly came under attack by insurgents and made repeated patrols of the countryside. His discharge comes just as his unit was training to return to Iraq.

The puppy-throwing video started spreading on YouTube and other places on the Internet on March 3. In it, one Marine says, "That's mean, Motari." The video made international headlines and prompted death threats from around the world against Motari's family in Monroe.

Now as the word of Motari's discharge spreads, the controversy has resurfaced on the Internet, with people venting and making fun of the Marine. A Flash animated game names Motari, and depicts a puppy firing a Marine from a missile launcher. A doctored version of the puppy-throwing video shows Motari tossing a Pokemon character instead. There's even a video featuring a rapping bulldog calling Motari out for a fight.

There is nothing funny about Motari's conduct, said Inga Gibson, Washington state director for the Humane Society of the United States.

She praised the Marine Corps for disciplining Motari.

One other Marine has been disciplined as a result of the video. Sgt. Crismarvin Banez Encarnacion, based in San Diego, has received a punishment.

Motari's mother said she and others in his family continue to be proud of the soon-to-be-­former Marine.

"The video released does not alter our opinion of him. The sun rises in the morning and sets in the evening," the statement read. "Life goes on no matter how much grief we may be in. My son's life will go on as will ours."



Reporter Yoshiaki Nohara: 425-339-3029 or ynohara@heraldnet.com.

1. Gay marriage issue can wait, say Referendum 71 partisans
2. Six injured, three critically, in wreck near Machias
3. Forecast for 2010 housing market: slow decline
4. First-time homebuyer credit invites tax cheats
5. That's Stud Muffin to you
6. Offensive line helps Marysville-Pilchuck rush into state playoffs
7. Glacier Peak freshman overcomes jitters to win state in cross country
8. Proud union member and veteran had a wild side
9. Snohomish County's former sanitation director claims his ouster was forced
10. More snow expected for Cascades, mountain passes
Enterprise Newspaper Snohomish County Business Journal
Gough on track to keep job
Jazz vocalist headlines NPAC
Mountlake Terrace makes football history
Tax revenue sagging, city budgets lagging
‘Touch of Magic' show opens at Gallery North
Jackson repeats as South champs
Holiday Bazaars Calendar
Meadowdale storms back to grab title
Edmonds moves to Fire District 1
The Enterprise Online Newspaper


Pacific Northwest
Fresh Cuisine

Free Dessert!
Click here!

15% Off Your
First Time Purchase

FREE Appetizer with any
purchase daily 2-6pm

Island Flavors with
Finest NW Ingredients

QuadraFire Save $250
Free Smart-Stat

50% off 2nd Pizza
Special Click Here!

Buffet Dining
Tulalip Resort

25% off Bath & Groom
New Customers

$5 OFF
Lunch or Dinner

Come and Relax
Monthly Specials

FREE Appetizer w/
purchase of 2 entrees

Great Food
24 Hours a Day

20% Off Dinner
Up to $75 Value!

Lube, Oil & Filter
Buy 1 - Get 1 FREE

$2 OFF
at Box Office

$5 Off
Stylecut

Oil - Snohomish County
Low Prices - Fill Now!

$1 off French Dip
$4.99 Burger Basket

20% off Click Here*
Buy 1 Offer Click Here*

All you can Eat Buffets
Angel of the Winds

Free Garlic Bread/Free Soda
Click here for details!

Family Night Free Sundae
$9.99 Prime Rib

Lube, Oil & Filter
Buy 1 - Get 1 FREE
American Car Care Center
TODAY'S TOP JOBS
 View All Top Jobs 
Top Cars
Top Homes

ADVERTISEMENT