Heraldnet.com
FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 5, 2008 3:39 am
LocalNorthwestNation & WorldPoliticsSpecial ReportsPhotosColumnistsMultimedia 
Blog
John Boyle
Willingham/practice notes
Blog
Aaron Swaney
Opening night
Latest gallery

Mill Creek Little League WS
August 17. 2008 (19 photos)
[More Herald photos]
 
WEEK IN REVIEW
Thursday
Skagit shooting victims' bodies being brought t...
Lockdown lifted at Lake Stevens schools
Marysville-Pilchuck out of lockdown; man arrest...
Wednesday


On the Kitty Hawk's last watch
Reardon keeping budget secret, some county lead...
Barista flasher charged with exposure; claims r...
Tuesday


Streets around Lake Stevens risky
Mukilteo couple to watch astronaut son blast off
Windows broken at Lynnwood parking lot
Monday


Fair's been quite a ride
Local delegates ready for GOP convention
Initiative targets illegal immigrants
Sunday


Everett lives in Scoop Jackson's shadow
On this weekend 40 years ago, Sultan really rocked
Bank records studied in Christian school sex case
Saturday
McCain's VP pick exciting to conservatives
Bothell road project will let colleges grow
Deputy is found not at fault in chase death
Friday


Local supporters are captivated by Obama's speech
'I thought I was dead,' teen rescued from Three...
More schools in state added to No Child Left Be...
 

ADVERTISEMENT

Sports   Print This Article  Email This Page  Subscribe Now! facebook digg reddit del.icio.us fark stumble

 
ADVERTISEMENT

 
mlb (External Link)
 
CONTACT THE HERALD
Report scores and results to 425-339-3470 or 1-866-6-SCORES (Call after 4:30 p.m.)
E-mail information including items for Tuesday's Communities Sports Roundup and Thursday's Outdoor Calendar, to sports@heraldnet.com
Kevin Brown, Sports Editor
kbrown@heraldnet.com
 
Published: Thursday, July 3, 2008

McNamee asks for Clemens suit to be dismissed

NEW YORK -- Brian McNamee asked a federal court late Wednesday to dismiss Roger Clemens' defamation lawsuit or move the case to New York.

Clemens, a seven-time Cy Young Award winner, sued McNamee in January after his former trainer accused him in the Mitchell Report of using steroids and human growth hormone. The case originally was filed in Texas state court and was shifted in February to the U.S. District Court in Houston.

McNamee's lawyers first tried to dismiss the case in early March. When Clemens' lawyers responded on May 27, they added a new claim of "intentional infliction of emotional distress" and two additional claims of defamation.

In their latest filing, McNamee's lawyers said New York has the most interest in this lawsuit and that many of the potential witnesses reside in New York. McNamee claims no defamation took place and that it would be a burden for him to defend the case in Texas.

"Mr. Clemens has so far pitched around Senator Mitchell, choosing not to sue him or Major League Baseball," McNamee's lawyer said in the motion.

McNamee's lawyers also said that because of the Texas statute of limitations, Clemens can't claim he was defamed by comments the trainer made to Andy Pettitte, Clemens' teammate, in 1999 or 2000, and 2003 or 2004.

McNamee said Clemens should have known as early as 2006 that McNamee and Pettitte believed Clemens used performance-enhancing drugs. Included in the filing was an e-mail from McNamee to Clemens from Oct. 1, 2006, which said that if Clemens thought "anything to do with me in regards to being a rat or flipping on you or anyone of my clients, I will hop on a plane, find you, and slap you very hard."

"In the end, Mr. Clemens cannot prevail because Mr. McNamee has the absolute defense of truth," McNamee's motion said. "Mr. McNamee has provided steroid paraphernalia, which will test positive for Clemens's DNA, to the federal government, and once the DNA results are revealed there will be little dispute about who is telling the truth."

McNamee also claims that he is immune from defamation because he made his comments to Mitchell at the behest of federal prosecutors.

In an interesting twist, McNamee said his statements weren't defamatory because he didn't accuse Clemens of doing anything wrong. He accused Clemens of using performance-enhancing drugs before players and owners agreed to ban them following the 2002 season.

"It is not per se contemptible or dishonest to be injected with steroids or HGH," McNamee's motion said. "Clemens is asking this court to infer that McNamee stated that Mr. Clemens cheated by knowingly using steroids and HGH to improve his pitching performance."

McNamee's motion also mentions that a divorce is pending with his wife and says that Clemens' former New York doorman could be called as a witness along with Angela Moyer, a bartender whom the Daily News linked to Clemens.

In an accompanying declaration, McNamee said he earned only about $3,000 between January and June.

1. Boeing Machinists vote to strike; union leaders say wait
2. Grim task of investigating Skagit County killings
3. 2 Lake Stevens schools in lockdown
4. Marysville-Pilchuck out of lockdown; man arrested nearby
5. New Glacier Peak High School dubbed 'pretty rad'
6. Boeing Machinists’ strike deferred
7. County Council says it was denied access to budget
8. Lockdown lifted at Lake Stevens schools
9. Don't miss out on settlement's payout
10. Couple's roadside lunch interrupted by attempted burglary
Enterprise Newspaper Snohomish County Business Journal
Bringing the world to Edmonds
FEMA turns to media to improve public image
Annexation's frustrations
A run for Charlotte
Annexation's frustrations
Minimalist food bars have local flavor
E-W aims for fifth straight league title
Wildcats moving forward
Terrace approves stormwater rate hike
The Enterprise Online Newspaper

TODAY'S TOP JOBS
 View All Top Jobs 
Top Cars
Top Homes


ADVERTISEMENT