Heraldnet.com
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 9, 2010 2:16 pm
LocalNorthwestNation & WorldPoliticsSpecial ReportsPhotosColumnistsMultimedia 
 
WEEK IN REVIEW
Monday


Lynnwood woman knew area's stories long before ...
Everett rethinks boutique wineries
A tidy lawn could be law in Lynnwood
Sunday


Marysville family comes together amid devastati...
Monroe Correctional Complex to lessen security ...
Extra patrols will be watching for drunken driv...
Saturday


Olympics are in the air
Everett police officers cleared in 2008 shootin...
Edmonds woman leaves gift of millions
Friday


Budget squeeze may close beloved Trafton school
Endgame near on airport flight debate?
Aaron Reardon laments political sparring with c...
Thursday


4-car police pileup in Everett under investigation
Edmonds educator, famous announcer dies
Bill would suspend limits on tax hikes
Wednesday


Citizenship classes: All for a better life
Many Snohomish County kids haven't had second d...
Snohomish County jail thrives under sheriff's m...
Tuesday


Mukilteo kids’ cards help Haitians
County Council increases scrutiny on Reardon
Pentagon report a good sign for Everett's Navy ...
 

ADVERTISEMENT

Entertainment   Print This Article  Email This Page  Subscribe Now! facebook digg reddit del.icio.us fark stumble

Ilion Animation Studios  (click to enlarge)
Neera (left), voiced by Jessica Biel, and Lem, voiced by Justin Long, star in the animated comedy “Planet 51.”
 
ADVERTISEMENT

 
 
CONTACT THE HERALD
Melanie Munk, Features Editor
munk@heraldnet.com
 
Published: Friday, November 20, 2009

'Planet 51': Alien-invasion tale goes from fun to dull

A Spanish animation studio, Ilion, gets into the kid-film sweepstakes with “Planet 51,” an underwhelming alien-invasion comedy.

The twist? The invading alien, in this case, is an American astronaut. Gung-ho Capt. Baker (voiced by Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson) finds himself stranded on Planet 51, sorely in need of help from the green-skinned denizens of the place.

Capt. Baker, however, isn't really the hero of the thing. In fact, the story is told from the perspective of the locals. The residents of Planet 51 seem to be living their version of the 1950s: white picket fences, backyard barbecues, a certain amount of societal repression.

I guess they're supposed to be the “little green men” people talked about in the 1950s when alien invaders were imagined. You might also note a suspicious resemblance to the world of “Shrek,” but let's not point fingers.

More alarmingly, although the females of Planet 51 wear modest dresses, the males of this planet wear no pants. Of course, the cartoon universe is like that.

Our hero is Lem (Justin Long), a somewhat nerdy dude who can't work up the nerve to ask out Neera (Jessica Biel). All of which will be settled by Lem's role in dealing with the crash-landed astronaut.

Other voices in the mix include Seann William Scott as Lem's goofy pal, Gary Oldman as a fearsome general and John Cleese as a brainiac professor.

“Planet 51” gets off to a perfectly decent start, assuming you can adjust to the no-pants spectacle. But once Capt. Baker goes into hiding, it's basically one long chase. One long chase that seems much longer than it really is.

I'm not sure why this movie is so tedious. It has a few cute jokes, the voice talent is fine, the animation is all right.

But boy, it does get boring. Maybe the simplicity of the story will keep kids diverted, but compare it to something like “Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs” — no world beater, but a fun movie — and it really comes up short.

There must have been a way to make the film's basic switcheroo fun: to swivel the alien-invasion movie and see it through the reverse lens. There must be a way, but this isn't it.



“Planet 51” ½

Animated reversal on the old alien-invasion movie from the 1950s: It still looks like the '50s, but the heroes are the green people on Planet 51, and the invader is a U.S. astronaut (voiced by Dwayne Johnson) who needs to get away from the puzzled locals. This should have been a decent premise, but the film is weirdly tedious.

Rated: PG for subject matter

Showing: Alderwood Mall, Everett, Galaxy Monroe, Marysville, Stanwood, Meridian, Metro, Thornton Place, Woodinville, Cascade Mall

COMMENTS | Be the first to comment

Log in or register to post a new comment.


To read other terms and conditions, click here

Other Advertisers
TODAY'S TOP JOBS
 View All Top Jobs 
Top Cars
Top Homes

ADVERTISEMENT