Juror’s ‘research’ forced mistrial in child rape case

EVERETT — A Snohomish County deputy prosecutor couldn’t bring himself to force a 6-year-old girl to take the witness stand again to testify against her father — the man accused of raping and molesting her.

The case was strong against the Bothell man. Eleven jurors had believed he was guilty before a mistrial was declared.

One juror had played by his own rules, ignoring repeated commands by the judge to only consider evidence presented at trial.

After the first day of testimony, the juror launched his own investigation. The defense lawyer had offered a theory during his opening statement that the girl had been coached. The juror went home, before ever hearing from the girl, and began researching online about witness coaching, court papers said.

His misconduct came to light during deliberations. Other jurors asked why he wasn’t convinced that the Bothell man was guilty. The man admitted he’d done his own research. His fellow jurors blew the whistle.

Superior Court Judge Richard Okrent questioned the man and later lectured him. The judge declared a mistrial.

Prosecutors considered whether to seek sanctions against the man.

“Initially I was angry, because I know what it takes to try these kinds of cases and I know what it puts victims through, but we don’t charge people to make a point or make someone an example. The damage was done,” Snohomish County Prosecuting Attorney Mark Roe said.

The case, however, highlights an increasing concern among lawyers and judges. Jurors, like many people these days, are accustomed to being connected by smartphones instantly to sources of information wherever they go. Technology makes it simple to check out the day’s headlines, join discussions on social media sites and Google any topic that piques a person’s interest.

About 85 percent of U.S. adults use the Internet, according to the Pew Research Center. About the same percentage own cell phones and more than half of those use their phones to go online.

Legal experts say the onslaught of technology in people’s daily lives increases the potential for jurors to read and hear information they’re ordered to avoid during trial.

“Jurors are facing a huge challenge with all this information literally in the palm of their hands,” Roe said.

It’s not just a problem in Snohomish County, but nationwide, Superior Court Judge Michael Downes said.

An Arkansas murder conviction was overturned after a juror, during the trial, posted about the case to his Twitter account. The Arkansas Supreme Court found that the man’s tweets, although one-sided, were public discussions. That’s a no-no and was enough for the court to find that the man’s failure to follow the judge’s order prejudiced the defendant.

There always have been instructions warning jurors not to seek outside evidence on their own, to inspect a crime scene, or to talk to anyone about the case, Downes said. Before being selected, jurors are questioned about whether they’ve been exposed to publicity about the case and whether that makes them unable to be impartial. Jurors are expected to decide a case solely on the information presented at trial and the laws judges instruct them to follow.

As Downes explained, the evidence is provided to both sides and everyone has a chance to investigate the information before it reaches a jury. The lawyers have the opportunity to interview witnesses and ascertain their reliability. Both sides can spend months and sometimes years investigating information. Based on the rules of evidence, judges decide what jurors can hear.

“There’s no reliability standard for what people post on the Internet,” Roe said.

There’s so much information out there and often times it’s just plain wrong, Everett defense attorney Karen Halverson said.

In the past, judges warned jurors to avoid stories in newspapers and radio and television broadcasts. Now, judges often have lengthy colloquies about what other sources of information jurors also should avoid, including Facebook, Twitter, blogs and text messages.

In their decision to reverse the murder conviction, justices on the Arkansas Supreme Court cited an opinion offered by the 3rd Circuit Court Appeals, which noted that “prejudicial communication may be greater when jurors comments on a blog or social media website than when she has a discussion about the case in person, given that the universe of individuals who are able to see and respond to a comment on Facebook or a blog is significantly larger.”

It isn’t unreasonable or unconstitutional for judges to require jurors to avoid the Internet during trials, University of Washington law professor Ryan Calo said.

“It’s reasonable, but I also think it’s difficult for jurors,” he said.

Downes said he doesn’t think it’s necessary for jurors to abstain from using the Internet during a trial. However, he does believe it’s a realistic expectation to ask to them to limit what they see and hear.

“The means of finding information may have changed, but the reason for the rules are still critically important,” Downes said.

Anecdotally, it appears more common for jurors to do their own research, the judge said.

He wonders whether it’s because people are used to having their questions answered instantly. They don’t need to go to the library to check out a book. They can just grab the smartphone in their pocket and type away.

“People may just be used to reaching for answers right away,” Downes said.

Snohomish County deputy prosecutor Andrew Alsdorf was left with a difficult decision after Okrent declared a mistrial in the child sex case. Based on the poll taken of the jury, Alsdorf was confident a second jury would convict the Bothell father if he took the case to trial a second time. However, he had to consider the victim, a 6-year-old girl, who already had endured sitting across from her father, telling a room full of strangers about the sexual abuse she suffered.

Alsdorf was compelled to negotiate a resolution that spared the little girl from having to testify again. He agreed to reduce the charges to three counts of incest, essentially reducing the man’s potential prison sentence from 15 years to five. If the man had been convicted of the original child rape and molestation charges, he also would have had to convince the Indeterminate Sentencing Board he was no longer a danger before being released from prison.

“The misconduct committed by one rogue juror who did not follow the court’s instructions in an effort to persuade his fellow jurors using methods specifically forbidden by the court, resulted in not only a mistrial but an injustice as well,” Alsdorf wrote. “It is truly unjust that the emotional fragility of the defendant’s daughter which the defendant helped create by sexually abusing her, is the primary factor that spared the defendant from retrial.”

There is no way to know how the juror would have voted if he hadn’t done his own research. Jurors disagree, and that’s the way the system is supposed to work, Calo said.

“Jurors give a voice to the public,” he said. “There’s all sorts of things that happen in the jury room.”

In this case, the juror crossed the line, Alsdorf said.

The Bothell father, who has maintained his innocence, agreed to a bench trial. Okrent on Friday found the man guilty and sentenced to him to five years in prison. The judge told the man he’d failed as a father and turned his daughter into a victim.

Meanwhile the girl’s mom criticized her ex-husband for breaking their daughter’s trust and refusing to accept responsibility for his actions.

“If we didn’t suffer a mistrial because of a reckless juror, he’d be in prison for 15 years,” the woman said.

Roe said it may be time to have a conversation about what more can be done to insulate jurors from outside influences while they’re impaneled, including ordering them to stay away from the Internet.

“I think we need to at least consider the next step,” Roe said.

The vast majority of jurors don’t engage in misconduct, Downes said.

Yet the judge recently was forced to declare a mistrial after a juror refused to return to court. She and the rest of the jury had deliberated for about two hours in a residential burglary trial. They were told to return the next day. Only 11 returned. The court’s jury coordinator called the woman, who said she simply wasn’t coming back.

Downes is considering whether to refer the case to the prosecutor’s office for possible charges against the runaway juror.

“We rely on people. They take an oath to follow the rules,” Downes said. “It’s a problem when people don’t take their jobs seriously.”

Diana Hefley: 425-339-3463; hefley@heraldnet.com.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

Trader Joe’s customers walk in and out of the store on Monday, Nov. 20, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
New Trader Joe’s opens this week at Everett Mall

It’s a short move from a longtime location, essentially across the street, where parking was often an adventure.

Ian Bramel-Allen enters a guilty plea to second-degree murder during a plea and sentencing hearing on Wednesday, March 6, 2024, at Snohomish County Superior Court in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
‘Deep remorse’: Man gets 17 years for friend’s fatal stabbing in Edmonds

Ian Bramel-Allen, 44, pleaded guilty Wednesday to second-degree murder for killing Bret Northcutt last year at a WinCo.

Firefighters respond to a small RV and a motorhome fire on Tuesday afternoon in Marysville. (Provided by Snohomish County Fire Distrct 22)
1 injured after RV fire, explosion near Marysville

The cause of the fire in the 11600 block of 81st Avenue NE had not been determined, fire officials said.

Ashton Dedmon appears in court during his sentencing hearing on Tuesday, March 5, 2024, at Snohomish County Superior Court in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Everett Navy sailor sentenced to 90 days for fatal hit and run

Ashton Dedmon crashed into Joshua Kollman and drove away. Dedmon, a petty officer on the USS Kidd, reported he had a panic attack.

A kindergarten student works on a computer at Emerson Elementary School on Wednesday, Feb. 28, 2024, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
‘¡Una erupción!’: Dual language programs expanding to 10 local schools

A new bill aims to support 10 new programs each year statewide. In Snohomish County, most follow a 90-10 model of Spanish and English.

Logo for news use featuring the Tulalip Indian Reservation in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Woman drives off cliff, dies on Tulalip Reservation

The woman fell 70 to 80 feet after driving off Priest Point Drive NW on Sunday afternoon.

Everett
Boy, 4, survives fall from Everett fourth-story apartment window

The child was being treated at Seattle Children’s. The city has a limited supply of window stops for low-income residents.

People head out to the water at low tide during an unseasonably warm day on Saturday, March 16, 2024, at Lighthouse Park in Mukilteo, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Everett shatters record high temperature by 11 degrees

On Saturday, it hit 73 degrees, breaking the previous record of 62 set in 2007.

Snohomish County Fire District #4 and Snohomish Regional Fire & Rescue respond to a motor vehicle collision for a car and pole. The driver was pronounced dead at the scene, near Triangle Bait & Tackle in Snohomish. (Snohomish County Sheriff’s Office)
Police: Troopers tried to stop driver before deadly crash in Snohomish

The man, 31, was driving at “a high rate of speed” when he crashed into a traffic light pole and died, investigators said.

Alan Dean, who is accused of the 1993 strangulation murder of 15-year-old Bothell girl Melissa Lee, appears in court during opening statements of his trial on Monday, March 18, 2024, at Snohomish County Superior Court in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
31 years later, trial opens in Bothell teen’s brutal killing

In April 1993, Melissa Lee’s body was found below Edgewater Creek Bridge. It would take 27 years to arrest Alan Dean in her death.

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Snohomish in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Man dies after crashing into pole in Snohomish

Just before 1 a.m., the driver crashed into a traffic light pole at the intersection of 2nd Street and Maple Avenue.

Bodies of two men recovered after falling into Eagle Falls near Index

Two men fell into the falls and did not resurface Saturday, authorities said. After a recovery effort, two bodies were found.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.