Student-athlete claims discrimination by Mukilteo district
The suit, filed earlier this month in U.S. District Court in Seattle by Keelie Shay, seeks unspecified damages for alleged gender and sexual-orientation discrimination and emotional harm by the school district.
Andy Muntz, school district spokesman, declined to comment because the issue is in litigation.
Shay later transferred to Mariner High School, where she participated in athletics, including the girls basketball team, and graduated in 2010. Shay is now 21 years old.
In 2009, Shay and her mother, Kristie Shay, filed a complaint outlining similar concerns with the state's Human Rights Commission, alleging she was denied the opportunity to participate in sports because of her sexual orientation.
The school district responded with an 11-page letter to the commission, asserting that there was no evidence of discrimination based on sexual orientation. Rather, it said, there was stiff competition for spots on the varsity team.
In 2010, the state commission decided there was insufficient evidence to show that an unfair practice had occurred.
Shay's attorney in the federal lawsuit, Marianne K. Jones, said the commission didn't thoroughly investigate the case.
"They did a very, very poor job," she said. One big error in its review of the case, Jones said, was not realizing that a senior could be permitted to play on a junior varsity team.
"She asked to participate anywhere they wanted her to participate, junior varsity or varsity," Jones said. But the coach "wouldn't allow her to participate at all."
Shay began her participation in athletics as a starter on Kamiak's junior varsity basketball team. Out-of-season practices were directed by a coach, Jody Schauer, who also directed the school's varsity team.
In December 2008, Shay was dating another player on the team, according to the suit. Shay announced her sexual orientation when their relationship became known to other members of the team, it says.
After the coach learned of Shay's sexual orientation, Shay no longer was a starter for the junior varsity team, her playing time was reduced and she was no longer coached as before, the suit alleges.
Shay alleges she was told by coaches that she would not be considered for any of the girls basketball teams at Kamiak High School, though the season was still eight months away.
Schauer allegedly advised Shay, then a 16-year-old junior, that if she wanted to participate on a team, she should transfer to another school.
Shay's mother hired an attorney and negotiated her daughter's participation in an unspecified basketball tournament. The "actions and words" of Schauer at the event "was discriminatory, abusive and bullyish," according to the lawsuit.
Schauer was later terminated as a coach, the suit says.
The district's actions in response to the issue was "too little and not effective," it adds.
Sharon Salyer: 425-339-3486; firstname.lastname@example.org.
Our new comment system is not supported in IE 7. Please upgrade your browser here.