Mariners want to know, what is a catch, and what is not?

SEATTLE — One thing is clear: players and managers are still confused.

Saturday night against the Oakland Athletics the Seattle Mariners went through two more rounds of trying to determine what is and is not a catch.

Twice, Seattle left fielder Dustin Ackley, a converted second baseman, dropped a transfer of the ball from his glove to throwing hand. Twice, runners were confused.

The first time, Ackley slid to his left and appeared to have caught a line drive with a runner on first. Pulling the ball out of his glove, he dropped it. It was immediately ruled no catch, but the Oakland runners were confused enough that both ended up on first base after passing each other between first and second.

Later in the game, Ackley again dropped the transfer following a Yoenis Cespedes fly ball. Ackley was again fortunate the play produced an out. Cespedes was so convinced it was a catch, he turned back toward the dugout. Eventually, the Mariners worked the ball back to first base to record a 7-6-3 out.

“I guess you really have to focus on the exchange now, that’s the most important part,” Ackley said. “I’m glad I didn’t have to learn the hard way.”

The Mariners have been involved in catch-or-not debates four times in 10 games. Twice with Ackley, once with center fielder Abraham Almonte and once with outfielder Josh Hamilton of the Los Angeles Angels.

The rule, and interpretation, of what is and what is not a catch has been changed this season. For instance, Major League Baseball says, “One example of a catch that would not count is if a fielder loses possession of the ball during the transfer before the ball was secured by his throwing hand.” That would be what happened to Ackley twice. It also happened to Hamilton.

All of which has Mariners manager Lloyd McClendon unclear as to what’s a catch and not.

“I’m as frustrated as the next person,” McClendon said. “You try to be politically correct with your statements, but I’m really worried about where we’re heading with replay … the effect that it’s having on the games and the effects it’s having on the fans.

“Hell, I don’t even know when to celebrate anymore. You don’t know if it’s going to be challenged. For me, I think it’s slowing the game down. I’ve been trying to be a fan of it. I initially, thought it was going to be good for the game, but I’m not so sure. I’m really not.”

Players have been discussing replay and the new rules internally. The Mariners’ representative in the players’ association is reliever Charlie Furbush. He said they haven’t had a discussion with Major League Baseball yet about the transfer rule.

“More of a work in a progress at this point,” Furbush said. “There’s nothing that I know of for changes to be happening any time soon.”

Ackley said he will begin to slow down transfers with no runners on base, opting to show the catch to an umpire. He also points out making a transfer from a larger outfielder’s glove, as opposed to the small models second basemen use, can be tricky.

But, with runners on base, he’s still going to make the transfer as quickly as possible.

“I think when it’s a situation where a guy’s tagging, you’ve just got to do what you can do,” Ackley said. “If you happen to drop it, you drop it.”

McClendon is searching for answers.

“It’s confusing as hell,” he said.

Defending Smoak

Justin Smoak’s efficient footwork and smooth picks at first base make his defense appear routine. It’s at a level that McClendon said is deserving of high recognition.

“I think he’s a Gold Glove type of first baseman,” McClendon said. “I think probably the reason he has not won a Gold Glove to this point is his offensive numbers haven’t been there. It’s funny. I’ve always said Gold Glove is more an offensive award than a defensive award. If you look at the first baseman’s in the league, I think he’s as good as any of them.”

Smoak was able to show his fielding ability again on Sunday when he grabbed a high hop and was able to get an out at second base.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Arlington’s Leyton Martin (2) poses for a photo at Arlington High School on Sunday, March 24, 2024 in Arlington, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
The Herald’s 2023-24 Boys Basketball Player of the Year: Leyton Martin

Arlington’s do-it-all junior point guard led the Eagles to a district title and second straight Hardwood Classic.

Left to right, Mountlake Terrace’s Zaveon Jones, Glacier Peak’s Jo Lee, Everett’s Isaiah White, Arlington’s Leyton Martin, Jackson’s Ryan McFerran, and Mountlake Terrace’s Jaxon Dubiel pose for a photo at Arlington High School on Sunday, March 24, 2024 in Arlington, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
The Herald’s 2023-24 All-Area boys basketball teams

A look at the top prep boys basketball players in the area from the 2023-24 season.

Silvertips’ Andrew Petruk (26) fights for the puck during a game between the Everett Silvertips and the Tri-City Americans at the Angel of the Winds Arena on Sunday, March 24, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Breaking down the Silvertips’ 1st-round playoff series vs. the Giants

Everett is searching for a revenge after a shocking playoff exit against Vancouver two years ago.

Left to right, Arlington’s Samara Morrow, Kamiak’s Bella Hasan, Everett’s Alana Washington, Lake Steven’s Nisa Ellis, Lynnwood’s Aniya Hooker, and Meadowdale’s Gia Powell, pose for a photo at Everett High School on March 24, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
The Herald’s 2023-24 All-Area girls basketball teams

A look at the top prep girls basketball players in the area from the 2023-24 season.

Everett’s Alana Washington poses for a photo at Everett High School on March 24, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
The Herald’s 2023-24 Girls Basketball Player of the Year: Alana Washington

The Everett senior upped her game in the postseason to help the Seagulls overcome injuries and claim their first state trophy in 41 years.

Silvertips players celebrate during a game between the Everett Silvertips and Tri-City Americans at the Angel of the Winds Arena on Sunday, Jan. 21, 2024. The Silvertips won, 5-3. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Silvertips land No. 1 pick, chance to draft generational talent

Landon DuPont is the consensus top pick in next WHL prospects draft. Everett chief operating officer Zoran Rajcic said the team intends to select him.

Dennis Williams, head coach and GM of the Everett Silvertips, shakes hands with an assistant coach at the end of a season opening victory over the Vancouver Giants on Saturday, Sep. 24, 2022, at Angel of the Winds Arena in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Coach, GM Williams leaving Silvertips for Bowling Green State

After seven successful season leading Everett, Dennis Williams is heading back to his alma mater. He’ll stay with the Tips through the WHL playoffs.

Stanwood High School student athletes during their signing day ceremony. (Courtesy of Stanwood High School)
Local class of 2024 athletes who have signed to play in college

A running list of 2024 high school athletes who are set to compete at the next level.

Mountlake Terrace’s Jaxon Dubiel talks with head coach Nalin Sood during the 3A boys state basketball game against Todd Beamer on Wednesday, Feb. 28, 2024 in Tacoma, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
‘It was just time’: Mountlake Terrace basketball coach Sood steps down

Nalin Sood guided his alma mater to 381 wins and 15 state berths in 24 seasons as head coach. He spent over four decades with the program.

University of Washington's new men's basketball coach Danny Sprinkle meets the news media, Wednesday, March 27, 2024 in Seattle. (Ken Lambert/The Seattle Times via AP)
Taking over at Washington personal for men’s basketball coach Sprinkle

Danny Sprinkle spoke about his connection to the school during his introductory press conference Wednesday.

X
Prep roundup for Tuesday, March 26

Prep roundup for Tuesday, March 26: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To report results… Continue reading

Washington State athletic director Pat Chun, center, watches players on the first day of NCAA college football practice, Friday, Aug. 6, 2021, in Pullman, Wash. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Washington hires AD Chun away from rival Washington State

UW quickly targeted its in-state rival’s athletic director after Troy Dannen’s sudden departure.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.