DETROIT — A judge overseeing Detroit’s bankruptcy refused Monday to stop the city from shutting off water if people can’t pay their bill.
Judge Steven Rhodes said the water department probably hasn’t done enough to help people with chronically low income, but noted there is no “enforceable right” to water.
Rhodes covered much ground as he read his opinion in court. He said Detroit’s recent strategy to get people into two-year payment plans, starting with a 10 percent down payment, was “bold” and “commendable.” Roughly 30,000 customers now are enrolled.
Bankruptcy law doesn’t grant the authority to interfere with city services, said Rhodes, who also turned aside constitutional arguments of due process and equal protection.
“Detroit cannot afford any revenue slippage,” said the judge, who heard two days of testimony last week.
Nearly 22,000 homes lost water due to shutoffs from March through August, according to the water department, and 15,251 had service restored in that same period.
The department said it would suffer financially if ordered to supply water without payment. “There are limits” to what the department can do, city attorney Thomas O’Brien said.
Rhodes has taken extraordinary interest in the plight of water customers. The city stopped shutoffs in July for more than 30 days after the judge said they were causing anger and bad publicity. Protesters marched, and even the United Nations criticized Detroit.
Talk to us
> Give us your news tips.
> Send us a letter to the editor.
> More Herald contact information.
