Mustards, of all styles, colors, and flavors from “apricot” to “Zinfandel,” have become big business. Everybody is getting into the act, in large part, I think, because the prospect of opening pretty little jars that promise such extravagant taste sensations is indeed beguiling.
But have you ever made your own? If your idea for making mustard has thus far consisted of stirring a little bit of water (or wine, or ale, or vinegar) into powdered mustard, then you’re in for a pleasant surprise. Even if you’ve taken that concept a step or so further by adding a sprinkling of herbs or sugar or egg yolks, you have yet to savor what a real homemade mustard can be.
You see, I believe in starting with the whole seeds. It’s the only way to achieve the purest, most balanced of mustard flavorings. Otherwise, you’re relying on whatever powdered mustard blend you happen to have purchased. And even if it’s Coleman’s — which most agree is the superior powdered mustard blend on the market — the flavors and textures you can create are limited.
But if you follow my two basic steps, you will truly have something to brag about. Something worthy of sharing with your most persnickety “gourmets” friends and family members.
Step 1: The soak. First, you will combine the seeds with the liquid and let the mixture sit for two days. This simple step — unlike most of the recipes for homemade mustard that I’ve encountered, but very similar to the process commercial mustard makers follow — makes all the difference.
By allowing the seeds time to absorb the liquid, to soften and plump, before adding other ingredients or pureeing in a food processor, the finished product is creamier and more richly flavored. Depending on the dryness of the seeds — and believe me, they do vary — you’ll notice that your seeds either lap up the liquid very quickly or slowly absorb the liquid over the extended time. It’s something you will need to monitor. Since the idea is to keep the seeds just barely covered with liquid, if you have a thirsty batch of seeds you’ll be adding additional liquid at more frequent intervals, especially during the first 24 hours.
Step 2: The blend. The thoroughly-plumped seeds and whatever liquid is still in solution with them are scraped into a food processor at this point so you can puree the mixture to the desired consistency.
This is usually the point at which you add any other ingredients, such as shallots, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh herbs or garlic. You may be surprised at how long my recipes instruct you to run the food processor. Generally, you keep the seeds in motion from 3 to 6 minutes, which is a long time by most blending standards. But if you’re patient, you’ll see the mixture transform before your eyes from one with defined seeds and liquid to a somewhat creamy, then a very creamy solution. As the seeds’ crispy hulls crack and break, the pulpy centers are thrown into solution where they help thicken and flavor the mustard.
The mustard seeds
Mustard gets its kick from three types of mustard seed: black, brown and white (commonly referred to as “yellow since the seeds are actually a pale yellow color). The black and brown seeds contribute the familiar “hot” or pungent flavor of mustard. The yellow mustard, although more mild, also contributes its own character, a distinctive mustard flavor.
Commercially available mustard powder is a combination of yellow and black or brown mustard seeds. For purchasing your whole mustard seeds, keep in mind that you should locate a store that sells them in bulk form. Those tiny tins from the spice aisle in your supermarket cost a fortune.
The liquids
When using mustard seeds or powder, the ultimate pungency is achieved with cold water, which facilitates enzymatic formation of the necessary essential oils. Acids, such as vinegar — and to a lesser degree, wine or beer — produce a less favorable environment for the enzyme, and thus, a slightly tamer condiment. But remember, “slightly” is the operative word. These mustard preparations are still potent, even after the flavors have improved and mellowed during the 2 to 3 week aging process.
I really like using vinegar in my recipes because I feel it helps to create a balance of flavors. When making your own mustards, remember that there are a plethora of vinegars to play around with. Beyond taste, however, you have to keep your ultimate color in mind. For instance, if you want a light, delicately colored mustard, don’t start with balsamic, malt, or red-wine vinegar, or a dark beer or red wine. Any of these ingredients will turn the mustard a dark or murky color.
Also, steer away from boiling-hot liquid. I’ve noticed that subjecting the seeds to temperatures at or near the boiling point (212 degrees at sea level) tends to make the final product rather bitter, or at the very least, flat. This carries through to the process of cooking with your mustards. The flavor tends to hold better when the mustard is added toward the end of the cooking process.
Storage and safety
Please store your mustards in the refrigerator. Although it’s hard to imagine any bacterium with half a brain wanting to reproduce in such a fiery potion, food-safety experts caution that it is a possibility. So it’s best to store questionable batches in the refrigerator. Questionable, by my definition, is any recipe calling for liquids other than just vinegar. When this is the case, you should mark your labels, “keep refrigerated.” Of course, most of these mustards will safely survive room temperature during the gift-giving phase or a short trip via mail.
German whole grain mustard
2/3 cup yellow mustard seeds
1/2 cup brown mustard seeds
3/4 cup cider vinegar
3/4 cup craft beer (choose something with significant malt and hops profile, such as a regional IPA or an amber ale)
3 cloves garlic, minced
2 teaspoons Worcestershire sauce
2 teaspoons salt
2 teaspoons sugar
2 teaspoons ground allspice
1/2 teaspoon turmeric
A classic mustard that would be perfectly at home on a slab of crusty bread with juicy chunks of knockwurst on the side. The turmeric provides the blush of gold, so don’t leave it out.
In a nonaluminum pot or jar, combine the mustard seeds, vinegar, ale, garlic, and Worcestershire sauce; cover and soak for 48 hours, adding additional vinegar and ale (in correct proportions) if necessary to maintain enough liquid to cover the seeds.
Scrape the soaked seeds into a food processor. Add the salt, sugar, allspice, and turmeric and process until the mustard turns to a coarse grained but creamy mixture flecked with seeds. This takes 2 to 3 minutes, so be patient.
Add additional vinegar and ale (in correct proportions) as necessary to create a nice creamy mustard; keep in mind that it will thicken slightly upon standing. This is one mustard I can hardly wait to sample, so letting it age, even for a week or two, is always a challenge. However, giving it a little time to develop in flavor before presening it to a friend does make it even better.
Makes 23/4 cups
Source: “The Mustard Book,” by Jan Roberts-Dominguez
Bordeaux mustard
2/3 cup yellow mustard seeds
1/2 cup brown mustard seeds
1 cup red wine vinegar
1/2 cups dry red wine, such as Cabernet Sauvignon, Pinot Noir, or Syrah
4 cloves garlic, minced
2 tablespoons sugar
2 tablespoons Worcestershire sauce
2 teaspoons salt
1/2 teaspoon dried tarragon, crumbled
1 teaspoon dried marjoram, crumbled
1 teaspoon ground white pepper
1 teaspoon turmeric
A whole-grained French mustard that’s delicious with sausage. Very, very classic. Very, very delicious.
In a nonaluminum pot or jar (I use a 1 quart sized canning jar), combine all the mustard seeds, vinegar, wine and garlic; cover and soak for 48 hours, adding additional vinegar and wine (in the correct proportions) if necessary to maintain enough liquid to cover the seeds.
Scrape the soaked seeds into a food processor. Add the remaining ingredients and process until the mustard turns from liquid and seeds to a creamy mixture flecked with seeds. This takes 3 to 4 minutes. Add additional vinegar and water (in correct proportions) as necessary to create a nice creamy mustard. Keep in mind that it will thicken slightly upon standing.
This mustard benefits from several weeks of aging. Keep refrigerated Makes about 31/3 cups.
Source: “The Mustard Book,” by Jan Roberts-Dominguez.
Whole-grain honey mustard with Pinot Noir
1 cup yellow mustard seeds
1/2 cup brown mustard seeds
11/2 cups Pinot Noir (or any medium- to full-bodied, dry red wine, such as a Syrah, Cabernet, or Zinfandel)
1/2 cup red wine vinegar
1/2 cup water
3 cloves garlic, minced
1 tablespoon dried chervil, crumbled
2 teaspoons paprika
2 teaspoons ground allspice
1/2 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
1/2 teaspoon ground cloves
1/2 teaspoon turmeric
1/2 teaspoon ground ginger
1/2 teaspoon ground nutmeg
1/2 teaspoon dried thyme, crumbled
5 tablespoons honey
This is a mustard designed to stand up to hearty fare. It’s chunky in character, bold and spicy in taste, and simply beguiling in the company of grilled kielbasa.
In a nonaluminum pot or jar (I use a 1 quart sized canning jar), combine all the ingredients except the honey, cover and soak for 48 hours, adding additional vinegar and water (in the correct proportions) if necessary to maintain enough liquid to cover the seeds.
Scrape half the mixture into a food processor. Process until the mustard turns from liquid and seeds to a creamy mixture flecked with seeds. This takes 3 to 4 minutes. Add additional vinegar and water (in correct proportions) as necessary to create a nice creamy mustard. Scrape this mixture into a bowl and combine with the remaining whole-seeds mixture. Stir in the honey. This mustard benefits from 2 to 3 weeks of aging.
Source: “The Mustard Book,” by Jan Roberts-Dominguez
Mustard of sun-dried tomatoes and basil
3/4 cup yellow mustard seeds
1 cup cider vinegar
3 cloves garlic, chopped
1 cup oil-packed sun-dried tomatoes, drained and chopped
1 tablespoon dried basil, crumbled
2 teaspoons salt
This has a beautiful, rich, golden-red color and is exquisitely flavored with sun-dried tomatoes and herbs. For a mustard, it’s unexpectedly mild, yet zestfully infused with tomato, basil, and garlic. Make plenty because as gifts go, this one will be a major hit with every foodie you know.
In a nonaluminum pot or jar (I use a 1 quart sized canning jar), combine the mustard seeds, vinegar, and garlic; cover and soak for 48 hours, adding additional vinegar if necessary to maintain enough liquid to cover the seeds.
Scrape the soaked seeds into a food processor. Add the remaining ingredients and process until the mustard turns from liquid and seeds to a creamy mixture flecked with seeds. Most of the tomato bits will eventually puree into a homogeneous mixture, blending splendidly with the mustard. This takes 3 to 4 minutes. Add additional vinegar as necessary to create a nice creamy mustard; keep in mind that it will thicken slightly upon standing. This mustard can be consumed immediately. Keep refrigerated. Makes 3 cups.
Source: “The Mustard Book,” by Jan Roberts-Dominguez
“The Mustard Book” meets Julia Child
Back in 1994, MacMillan Publishing published my book on making mustard from scratch. It was titled “The Mustard Book,” and contained everything you needed to know to produce your own really delicious mustards.
The year after the book was released, I spent 40 minutes in a private interview with Julia Child. Worried that I’d be tongue-tied, I arrived at the interview with an ice breaker of sorts.
But Julia (“May I call you that?” “Of Course.”) was easy to warm up to. She was 85 at that point, keeping up the sort of professional pace that would do-in lesser mortals of younger years, and sat before me rarin’ to go. Gentle smile and sparkling eyes, she began to talk the moment we sat down. Ever conscious, perhaps, of the precious few moments we all want to have with her.
Still, I opened with my ice breaker …
Me: Before we get started, I wanted to thank you personally for something that you did for me last year.
Julia: What was that?
Me: Well, I had a book come out in the fall, and when you were on “Good Morning America” with Joan Lunden you held it up on air.
Julia: What book was that?
Me: It was “The Mustard Book.”
Julia: Oh I remember that. It was a wonderful little book!
Me: That’s what you said! And I didn’t know you were going to do that and I started getting calls.
Julia: Well that’s just lovely, Jan.
Sadly, even with Julia’s ringing endorsement, “The Mustard Book” is no longer in print. But the recipes live on.
Talk to us
> Give us your news tips.
> Send us a letter to the editor.
> More Herald contact information.
