A way to protect health and jobs

We may now have a way to eat our fish and have our jobs, too.

The state Department of Ecology on Monday proposed a new water quality rule that, based on a realistic amount of fish consumption, will set pollution standards for rivers, lakes and other bodies of water and will allow industry, specifically Boeing and other manufacturers, to comply with those standards, reduce the amount of toxic chemicals being released into the environment and do so in an affordable, transparent manner.

Previously, acceptable levels of toxins were based on the amount of fish we supposedly consume, an estimate set in a 1974 federal study of 6.5 grams a day, less than 2 ounces a week. That’s about one and a half fish sticks a week, a ridiculous amount that Ivar Haglund would not have kept clam over. The new fish consumption standard assumes a much healthier and more generous rate of about a six-ounce serving a day of fish from state waters.

The new rule is tied to toxics-reduction legislation sought by Gov. Jay Inslee that seeks a greater emphasis on preventing toxic chemicals from entering the environment on the front end, rather than trying to clean them up on the back end where they enter the food web from wastewater discharges. Much of the toxic chemicals enter into the environment in small but steady amounts, such as copper from brake pads on vehicles, flame retardants in furniture, softeners used to make plastics and metals in roofing materials.

The rule and legislation seek to create chemical action plans that will bring together agencies, industry and others to recommend ways to reduce and eliminate specific chemicals and, where possible, find safer alternatives or procedures to those chemicals.

The updated water quality standards will be more stringent regarding about 70 percent of chemicals and will remain at current levels for about 30 percent. The only exception is made for arsenic because it occurs naturally at a relatively higher rate in state waters. A federal drinking water standard will instead be used for arsenic levels.

Agricultural use of pesticides and related chemicals would remain under the control of federal law. And the Ecology Department says the new standards it seeks should create minimal costs for most wastewater dischargers.

Reaction to the proposal from industry, environmentalists and the state’s Indian tribes, whose members’ diet and culture relies even more substantially on fish and seafood, will follow. But Rob Duff, environmental policy adviser for Inslee, in a telephone conference Monday said the Department of Ecology has worked to include those stakeholders in development of the rule and its legislation.

While this moves through the Legislature this session, the federal Environmental Protection Agency is keeping a keen watch on the process and has started its own rule-making process to update the state’s water quality standards should the state falter and fail to adopt new standards.

These are our waters, our fish and our industries. It’s best for all three if we adopt our rules.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Best editorial cartoons of 2024, Vol. 3

A sketchy look at the news of 2024, July through September.… Continue reading

Artist Natalie Niblack works amongst her project entitled “33 Birds / Three Degrees” during the setup for Exploring The Edge at Schack Art Center on Sunday, March 19, 2023, in Everett, Washington. The paintings feature motion-activated speakers that play each bird’s unique call. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Editorial: An opinionated look back at 2024’s Herald editorials

Among highlights and lowlights: Boeing’s struggles, light rail’s arrival and the return of orcas.

Turning off an alarm clock
Comment: To beat the daily grind, put some thought into it

A philosopher offers three tips for renewing interest in a life that’s fallen into the same-old routine.

Give Herald reporters resources they need

I am taken aback by The Herald management’s demands of the Everett… Continue reading

Comment: Drug-pricing program’s benefits often diverted

Reforms are needed to make sure savings benefit low-income families, and not health care providers.

Comment: State policy on trust lands strikes right balance

Anti-forestry groups have made incorrect claims that the state can’t harvest older stands of trees.

Comment: State’s lawmakers have selves to blame for budget hole

Rather than impose tax increases, lawmakers should follow other states’ lead on taxpayer rebates.

Forum: ‘Stand-up Cult’ follows muffin tin liners, not one-liners

You can keep your air fryers; for kitchen aficionados, the ultimate customizable appliance is the mixer.

toon
Best editorial cartoons or 2024, Vol. 2

A sketchy look at the news of 2024, April through June.… Continue reading

toon
Best editorial cartoons of 2024, Vol. 1

A sketchy look back at the news of 2024, January through March.… Continue reading

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, Dec. 27

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Forum: Set state DNR back on path to preserving resources

A recentering of needs must place more focus on the web of species that depend upon forest environments.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.