Perhaps it is hard to be a god, according to the title of this sprawling Russian epic. But everybody else looks miserable too.
We are in a world called Arkanar, invented by Arkady and Boris Strugatsky for a speculative 1964 novel that must be easier to understand than this film.
Arkanar is a pigsty, a horror show, a decadent party at James Franco’s house. It resembles the muddier years of Earth’s Middle Ages, but we are told it is a planet where the society has developed more slowly than ours.
We are also told (and this is important to grasp in the movie’s swirl) that our main character, Don Rumata (Leonid Yarmolnik), is actually a visitor from Earth. He pretends to be a god in Arkanar, passing through the squalid society and observing it.
The film’s 177 minutes are oozing with bodily fluids, casual brutality, and complete disdain for anything like conventional suspense or storytelling. Director Aleksei German uses black-and-white and an incredibly complex soundtrack to immerse us in this unpleasant world, his camera snaking around cramped interiors and muddy hillsides.
It would be no exaggeration to claim “Hard to Be a God” as one of the most densely designed movies ever made; somewhere in the world Terry Gilliam is weeping in despair at ever approaching its level of beastly creativity.
German (who died in 2013, before completing post-production) was some kind of visionary, and labored for many years on this project. His previous movie, “Khrustalyov, My Car!” (1998), was arguably more connected to recognizable reality, but was just as baffling in its refusal to submit to audience expectations.
Presumably German is showing us human existence, refracted through his cracked lens. But the film seems less about ideas than about creating a troubling experience, one in which the viewer is constantly assailed by things being thrown at the camera: birds, weapons, excrement.
As a fully-imagined carnival, “Hard to Be a God” is astonishing, but it’s hard to discern how it sheds light on mankind’s backward character, or guess for whom the film is intended. “I’m speaking to you,” says a character in the film, “but that doesn’t mean we’re having a conversation.”
We are shown that the world is a cesspool, in repetitive detail, for three hours. It’s an incredible looking-and-sounding immersion, but not quite a conversation.
“Hard to Be a God” (three stars)
A three-hour Russian epic about a visitor to a planet experiencing the equivalent of Earth’s Middle Ages. Visionary director Aleksei German buries the audience in bodily fluids and casual brutality, and while the movie is an incredible feat of design, it’s not always clear how this illuminates the human condition. In Russian, with English subtitles.
Rating: Not rated; probably R for violence, nudity
Showing: Northwest Film Forum
Talk to us
> Give us your news tips.
> Send us a letter to the editor.
> More Herald contact information.
