Dr. Paul on the art of not asking toddlers open-ended questions

Many parents offer their youngsters too many choices — too many possibilities for their little minds to absorb.

Several weeks ago, my wife and I were able to help our daughter when she was delivering her new baby boy. I took care of our 3-year-old granddaughter when my daughter went into labor. My wife attended the birth.

On Jan. 31, Simon, at over 9 pounds and 23 inches came into the world — no doubt, at that size, a future linebacker for the Seattle Seahawks!

I got to spend a lot of time with my 3-year-old granddaughter and observe her family’s interactions with her. Toddlers are the coolest creatures around. They are curious about everything: “Grandpa, why can’t I go to the hospital to be with Mommy when she has Baby Simon?” “Why does the grass grow?”

They want to understand everything. They see humor everywhere. They’re delightful. Except when they’re not.

But as most parents know, toddlers can be like Genghis Kahn when they want something. When they want something, they practice persistence with a vengeance. They can try the patience of a parent applying for sainthood.

Many parents offer their youngsters too many choices — too many possibilities for their little minds to absorb. I heard questions like: “What would you like for lunch?” or “What would you like to do this morning?” Open-ended questions like these are mind-boggling to a toddler. And what if they come up with something that’s not on the approved list?

Trust me, toddlers specialize in the quirky. “What would you like for breakfast?” asks Dad. “I want chocolate ice cream,” the toddler replies. Now we’re in for a toddler tussle.

So, what makes sense for our toddlers?

Offer two choices — no more. Sure, we want our kids to make decisions. But little minds prefer structure and predictability. Too much freedom and too many options can be anxiety provoking. And little kids can’t understand why they can’t eat ice cream for breakfast. Of course, they could — but would it be a healthy choice? The “why” questions that follow will drive you nuts.

Don’t negotiate. Toddlers, especially 2- to 4-year-olds, argue their point like Attila the Hun. Their basic approach — take no prisoners. It’s fun to watch an adult try to negotiate with a toddler. It’s like watching a dog chase its tail — lots of action with no result.

Pick your battles and stick to your guns. Maybe it’s not so important that Sarah wants to watch “Dinosaur Train” versus “Daniel the Tiger” — but ice cream for breakfast? Pizza three times a day? Two hours of screen time? When you make a decision, do not waiver, give in, or give up. Children need to learn that moms and dads are in charge. “No” always means no, no matter how high the volume gets. When little kids know that their parents are running the show, they settle down. They feel more secure.

Validate their feelings. Tolerate their frustration. Be consistent. “I know you really love ice cream,” I said. “I know you’re mad. But ice cream isn’t a breakfast food. Would you like an egg or some cereal?” I listened to a couple of minutes of “why” before I repeated her two choices. She wasn’t happy — but she did eat her egg sandwich.

She knew grandpa Paul wasn’t going to cave.

Paul Schoenfeld is a psychologist at The Everett Clinic. His Family Talk blog can be found at www.everettclinic.com/family-talk-blog.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Life

AquaSox General Manager Danny Tetzlaff keeps the whole circus running. (File photo)
Part baseball, part circus: What goes into a game at Funko Field?

It takes a small army of employees to make sure fans have a great time watching the Everett AquaSox.

Arlo Frostad, 7, and his twin brother Harrison Frostad, walk through the fields of Roozengaarde outside of Mount Vernon, Washington during the Skagit Valley Tulip Festival on April 10, 2025. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
Stop and smell the flowers at Skagit Valley Tulip Festival

The largest tulip festival in North America features five gardens and runs through April.

Image from Pexels.com
Top 3 Cannabis Shops You’ll Love in Snohomish County

Looking for quality products and good energy? Let’s discover the top spots.

The 2025 Lexus TX 350 is a three-row luxury SUV. It’s offered in Base, Premium, Luxury, and F Sport Handling grades (Provided by Lexus).
2025 Lexus TX 350 welcomes new F Sport Handling model

Unique exterior highlights, a glass roof and sport-tuned suspension are among the attractions.

Hybrid Touring Photo Provided by Subaru U.S. Media Center
2025 Subaru Forester Hybrid Increases Fuel Economy And Range

Sixth-Generation Model Receives Complete Refresh

Image from Canva.com
Chic & unique: The top 3 boutiques in Snohomish County you need to visit

From trendy finds to timeless pieces, discover the hidden gems that are redefining local fashion.

Image from Canva.com
Find your next favorite read in Snohomish County

Explore three of the finest bookshops where stories and community come together

Image from Canva.com
Say “I Do” to these stunning wedding venues

From rustic barns to elegant halls, discover where love stories in Snohomish County begin.

Grayson Bed and Breakfast (Photo courtesy of HD Estates and Grayson Bed and Breakfast)
The Grayson Bed and Breakfast: Where strangers become friends

A cozy retreat with scenic views and pet-friendly amenities just two miles from downtown Monroe.

Image from Prince Life Photography website.
Light, lens & love: These photographers bring the magic

Want to see who’s turning everyday moments into jaw-dropping memories? Let’s find out.

Small SUV Provides Big Time Value. Photo Provided by Chevrolet Newsroom
2025 Chevy Trax Activ Delivers Beyond Expectations

Sub-Compact SUV Surprises With Value And Features

Hai Viet Hong, center, performs with the Huong Viet Performing Arts Group during The Wendt Mayor’s Arts Awards on Thursday, April 10 in Everett, Washington. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
Everett artists celebrated with The Wendt Mayor’s Arts Awards

Award recipients included a former City Council member and the former publisher of My Everett News.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.