Fox’s actions contradict its ‘fair and balanced’ mantra

  • By Victor Balta / Herald Columnist
  • Wednesday, September 1, 2004 9:00pm
  • LifeGo-See-Do

Fox News is a flip flopper.

Last month, while hardly covering the Democratic National Convention in Boston, the channel’s prime-time super host Bill O’Reilly said that the news network’s job at these conventions is “not bring you wall-to-wall blather.”

The network refused to cover any of what it called “partisan speech” and said it would do the same at the Republican National Convention, which started Monday night in New York.

So, you can imagine my surprise when I tuned in Monday night and found Fox News anchor Shepard Smith telling me that Fox News will take viewers through the Republican convention “from gavel-to-gavel.”

Surely, “wall-to-wall” and “gavel-to-gavel” are different.

Indeed, Fox News gave viewers speeches by Sen. John McCain and former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani in their entirety – 25 minutes for McCain, 40 for Giuliani.

In July, former Vice President and presidential candidate Al Gore got a whopping 45 seconds of face time during his speech at the Democratic convention, and Fox granted former President and Nobel Peace Prize winner Jimmy Carter less than five minutes.

Other things you saw on Fox at the Republican convention on Day 1 that you didn’t see at the Democratic convention included the Pledge of Allegiance, the singing of the National Anthem and the entire ceremony acknowledging Sept. 11, 2001.

The main “news” on Day 1 of the Democratic convention was presidential nominee John Kerry’s first pitch at a Red Sox game, his visit to Cape Canaveral, where he wore a plastic suit, and his wife’s suggestion to a news reporter that he “shove it.”

Monday’s news was entirely different, offering an exclusive interview with Giuliani by talk-show host Sean Hannity, and a little focus on the protests going on outside the convention.

Those protests have been, by all accounts, peaceful.

Still Smith, the fair-and-balanced news anchor that he is, sought to compare this week’s peaceful protests to the ugly event in Chicago 36 years ago, saying, “this is the largest protest at a political convention since all that mess in Chicago back in 1968. “

In Chicago, 119 police officers and 100 protesters were reportedly injured in riots and melees that spanned a few days.

But the main flaw in Fox News’ staunch philosophy on what’s news and what isn’t came at the constant barrage of McCain and Giuliani coverage.

McCain is essentially a Democrat who turns into a Republican every election cycle, and Giuliani differs from the party platform on several of the litmus-test issues, like abortion, gun control and gay rights.

Still, Fox News held the pair up, just as Republican strategists knew they would, as the face of the Republican Party.

O’Reilly – who previously blew off Gore and Carter and everything they had to say as “nothing new” – praised McCain and Giuliani, calling the pair a “pretty powerful juggernaut.”

The new messages they had to offer were that President George W. Bush was right to invade Iraq and that he responded well after Sept. 11. Gee, I’ve never heard that spiel.

The icing on the cake, though, was Fox anchor Brit Hume’s assessment of the two speeches. Asking a panel of pundits about McCain and Giuliani’s performances, Hume said, “We know, of course, they were seen not by all the major networks, but certainly on the cable channels.”

Yes, Brit. We can always count on you to bring us all the coverage from a political convention – as long it’s the right convention.

Columnist Victor Balta: 425-339-3455 or vbalta@heraldnet.com.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Life

David Austin English Roses (Image from Sunnyside Nursery website).
Where greenery thrives: The most delightful nurseries in Snohomish County

Looking to add life to your space? These nurseries have just what you need!

The previous Volvo XC Recharge is now the 2025 Volvo EX40 (Provided by Volvo).
2025 Volvo EX40 is the new XC Recharge

The compact SUV is still electric and still resplendent.

Work And Play With Confidence. Photo Provided by Chevy Newsroom.
2025 Chevy Silverado 1500 Turbo-Diesel Delivers 25 MPG

ZR2 4WD Package Adds Off-Road Weekend Versatility

(Image from pexels.com)
Find your flow: The most inspiring yoga studios in Snohomish County

Looking for a place to stretch, strengthen, and find your zen? Herald readers have you covered.

Relax Mind & Body Massage (Photo provided by Sharon Ingrum)
Unwind, relax, and recharge at these top massage spots

Need a break? Discover where to find the most soothing and rejuvenating massages in Snhomish County

(Image from the website).
Finding comfort and care: Top assisted living communities in Snohomish County

Which assisted living communities offer the best care and quality of life? Let’s find out.

Since 1957, Sherwood Community Services has been a place where people with disabilities have the opportunity to live full, independent lives as part of their community.
The top three local nonprofits making a real impact in our community

Which local organizations are leading the way in impact and service? Let’s find out.

2025 Toyota GR Corolla four-door hatchback sports car (Provided by Toyota).
2025 Toyota GR Corolla available with an automatic transmission

For the first two years, a six-speed manual was its only gearbox.

Whidbey Clay Center instructor Jordan Jones demonstrates shaping a lump of clay into a gumdrop shape and centering the hole during her class at the Whidbey Clay Center in Freeland. Centering the holes is an important first step to turn clumps of mud into art, whether it be a mug, bowl, spoon rest, dragon, wagon or farm animal. (Patricia Guthrie / Special to The Herald)
Whidbey Island clay artists mucking in mud more than ever

Instructor to class: “Clay is very humbling. But you can remake it. It’s just mud. We’re just having fun.”

Photo provided by Mercedes-Benz USA Online Newsroom
2024 Mercedes GLC 43 Offers Luxury, Style And Performance

On- Or Off-Road, This Versatile Coupe Excels

The Port of Everett is hosting Sail-In Cinema again this summer at Boxcar Park. (Port of Everett)
The must-attend events that defined the year in Snohomish County

Which unforgettable experiences brought the community together? Let’s find out.

A person pauses to look at an art piece during the Schack Art Center’s 50th anniversary celebration on Thursday, Oct. 10, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Immerse yourself in the finest art galleries in Snohomish County

Ready to be inspired? Explore these stunning spaces filled with masterpieces!

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.