Crews work on the components for the autoclave at the 777X Composite Wing Center at Paine Field in Everett on May 19, 2016. (Kevin Clark / Herald file)

Crews work on the components for the autoclave at the 777X Composite Wing Center at Paine Field in Everett on May 19, 2016. (Kevin Clark / Herald file)

‘Clawback’ could make a comeback in aerospace tax break debate

Boeing and other firms rebut an auditor’s claim that it’s unclear if incentives are spurring job growth.

OLYMPIA — Aerospace companies that save bundles of dollars through tax breaks — billions in the case of the Boeing Co. — rallied Thursday against renewed calls for knitting a firm’s receipt of those perks with the number of people they employ.

Executives of Boeing and several firms voiced concerns at a public hearing on a report examining whether the tax breaks enacted in 2003 and extended in 2013 were doing what lawmakers wanted them to do — namely cut business costs, preserve the industry, ensure good-paying jobs, and “maintain and grow” the aerospace workforce.

That analysis by the state legislative auditor found costs are lower and workers are earning good wages, but there is no clear link between the tax breaks and job creation. There are more aerospace workers in Washington now than in 2003, but fewer than in 2013, it found.

Moreover, the auditor couldn’t find clear evidence that the tax break extension influenced Boeing’s decision to build the 777X in Everett.

The auditor is recommending lawmakers amend existing law to add another goal, like a baseline level of employment for companies receiving tax breaks. That would make it easier in future audits to figure out if they are paying off.

Aerospace officials rebutted the need for such clarification at Thursday’s hearing of the Citizens Commission for the Performance Measurement of Tax Preferences. The panel will decide next month whether to endorse the auditor’s suggestions before they are sent to lawmakers.

The preferences “are working exactly as intended,” said Emily Wittman, president and CEO of the Aerospace Futures Alliance, which lobbies on behalf of the industry.

Clay Hill, government affairs director for the Association of Washington Business, urged the five-member commission not to endorse the auditor’s finding and assess the success of the tax breaks from their beginning, in 2003. In that light, aerospace employment statewide is 38 percent higher and there are many more companies in the industry.

“When performance is properly measured, the facts are unmistakably clear,” he said.

State lawmakers and then-Gov. Gary Locke enacted incentives for the aerospace industry in 2003 to land the 787 Dreamliner assembly line for Washington. Those tax preferences were to expire in 2024.

During a November 2013 special session, legislators and Gov. Jay Inslee agreed to a 16-year extension, to 2040, to help convince Boeing to build the 777X in the state. It is projected the extension will enable aerospace firms to save close to $8.7 billion in tax payments, nearly all of it accruing to Boeing.

Bill McSherry, vice president of government operations for the Boeing Co., assured commissioners of the importance of the 2013 action.

“As a direct result of the extension of the tax incentives in 2013 and the contract with our manufacturing union, the IAM, Boeing made a $1 billion investment in Everett to construct the 777X composite wing center,” he said. “The incentives were a deciding factor in siting the 777X in the state.”

Andy Nicholas, associate director for the Washington State Budget and Policy Center, urged commissioners to back the auditor’s recommendation. He also suggested they go further and ask lawmakers to enact changes allowing portions of tax breaks to be “clawed back” by the state when job creation goals are not met.

“We are deeply concerned about the steep aerospace job losses our state has endured since the tax subsidy program was expanded,” he said. “To be honest, what people care about when it comes to these subsidies are good jobs. That is the goal Washingtonians are very concerned about here and I think there’s strong reason to believe we’re not getting our money’s worth.”

Nicholas also said he didn’t think the 2013 extension played a big role in Boeing’s decision.

During a spirited exchange on the subject with Commissioner Ronald Bueing, Nicholas said he is “not convinced” tax breaks alone actually change a company’s behavior.

“What it really tells us is what we already know — it was successful in one thing, reducing Boeing’s taxes,” he said.

The citizen commission tackled this same subject in late 2014 following the last review of aerospace tax breaks.

At that time, the bipartisan 16-lawmaker Joint Legislative Audit Review Committee recommended there be new requirements for businesses to set measurable goals of job creation or maintenance, and to certify with the state Department of Revenue the number of jobs created from the use of tax preferences. The auditor had a similar suggestion — backed by the commission — that lawmakers provide more detail on what they wanted to see such as any desired increase in jobs.

Legislation did get introduced in 2015 and 2016 that would have tied Boeing’s continued receipt of tax breaks to its employment levels. But it did not receive a vote.

Hill, of the Association of Washington Business, told commissioners Thursday the lack of action was the Legislature’s way of saying it is comfortable with the level of clarity in the law.

On Oct. 9, the panel will decide whether to endorse the legislative auditor’s suggested changes.

“There’s absolutely no doubt the aerospace industry is hugely important to the Washington economy,” Andi Nofziger-Meadows, a commissioner and president of the Edmonds Education Association, said after the meeting.

“I don’t think that having clear performance targets is a bad thing,” she said. “What those performance targets are for the industry is not for us to decide. I am always in favor of having clear performance targets.”

Jerry Cornfield: 360-352-8623; jcornfield@herald net.com. Twitter: @dospueblos.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

Oliver Popa, 7, poses with his book, "Drippey Plants a Garden," on Tuesday, March 25, 2025 in Edmonds, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Edmonds 7-year-old publishes children’s book featuring ‘Drippey’ the bee

Oliver Popa’s first grade teacher said he should publish a longer version of a writing assignment. A year later, his mother — a publisher — helped made it happen.

Don Sharrett talks John Wrice through his trimming technique on Friday, March 14, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Everett barber school offers $5 haircuts — if you’re brave enough

Students get hands-on practice. Willing clients get a sweet deal.

Employees and patrons of the Everett Mall signed a timeline mural that traces the history of the 51-year-old indoor mall that was once considered the premier place to go shopping in the city. Thursday, March 20, 2025 (Aaron Kennedy / The Herald)
Mall mural offers nostalgic trip into the past

Past and present Everett Mall employees joined customers Thursday to view an artistic timeline of the once popular shopping mecca.

2025 Emerging Leader Anthony Hawley (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Anthony Hawley: Creating friendships and filling pantries

Since 2021, Hawley has increased donations to Lake Stevens Community Food Bank through fundraising and building donor relationships.

Gary Petershagen
Lake Stevens council member announces reelection run

Gary Petershagen is seeking a third term on the council.

2025 Emerging Leader Megan Kemmett (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Megan Kemmett: Seeking solutions to any problem or obstacle

Executive director of Snohomish Community Food Bank overcomes obstacles to keep people fed.

Director for the Snohomish County Health Department Dennis Worsham leads a short exercise during the Edge of Amazing event on Tuesday, Oct. 1, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Snohomish County Health Department faces up to $3.4 million in cuts

The two federal grants provided funding for immunizations and disease prevention awareness efforts.

2025 Emerging Leader DeLon Lewis (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
DeLon Lewis: Helping students succeed

Program specialist for Everett Community College believes leadership is about building bridges.

Daron Johnson, who runs Snohomish County Scanner, stands next to his scanner setup on Tuesday, April 1 in Everett, Washington. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
Snohomish County law enforcement to encrypt police airwaves

The plan for civilian police scanners to go dark pushed a host to shut down his popular breaking news feed.

Richie Gabriel, 1, jumps off the bottom of the slide as Matthew Gabriel looks down at him from the play structure at Hummingbird Hill Park on Monday, March 31, 2025 in Edmonds, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Edmonds residents show up for Hummingbird Hill Park, Frances Anderson Center

After a two-and-a-half hour public comment session, the council tabled its votes for the two comprehensive plan amendments.

Students Haddie Shorb, 9, left, and brother Elden Shorb, 11, right, lead the ground breaking at Jackson Elementary School on Tuesday, April 1, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Everett Public Schools breaks ground on Jackson Elementary replacement

The $54 million project will completely replace the aging elementary school. Students are set to move in by the 2026-27 school year.

Logo for news use featuring Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Another positive measles case identified in Snohomish County

The case was identified in an infant who likely contracted measles while traveling, the county health department said.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.