Comment: Law, compassion required Housing First for shelters

Mandating treatment for addiction would have jeopardized federal funding for the purchase of the two hotels.

By Megan Dunn / For The Herald

During a week where our area had the unhealthiest air quality in the world which made it unsafe to be outside, the Snohomish County Council successfully stopped a proposal that would have left people out on the streets.

The council rejected, along party lines of 3-2, a change that would have mandated drug treatment in exchange for housing in the two hotels recently purchased using American Rescue Plan dollars. The hotels will be renovated to immediately add more than 150 new units for emergency shelter with wrap-around services and constant staffing, potentially in time for our cold weather.

The failed proposal to mandate treatment in exchange for housing is not only ineffective, inefficient and cruel, proposing it also violated public trust. The policy would risk the federal funding source and could not be implemented for these hotels that are to be purchased with federal funds. In addition to violating the ARPA funding source requirements, the county would stand to lose another $20 million a year in federal housing funds, which require using a Housing First model.

Additionally, people who have substance use disorder have a medical condition recognized under the American Disabilities Act. The ADA prevents discrimination so the county can’t deny housing because of a medical condition such as diabetes or a physical disability. Similarly, we can’t deny people trying to find services or a safe place to live because of substance use disorder.

Leaving people out on the street who are struggling with substance use does not make the public safer and it does not help with their addiction. Helping a person find stability with housing first is proven to work. We were elected to spend taxpayers’ dollars responsibility, which means funding programs that are a proven model and do not put the county at risk or violating a person’s constitutional rights under ADA. Thankfully, a majority of the council voted to make a smart, humane and fiscally responsible investment based on best practice by approving the purchase the of hotels and supporting the Housing First model. We choose to treat people with dignity and promote public safety by providing low barrier shelter.

We are rising to the challenges that impact our residents and our local businesses and working directly on solutions that work to end homelessness, provide needed treatment, and get people off the streets and into the safety of the indoors. When the rest of the council is ready to start working on solutions instead of thoughtless delays, I hope they will join us.

Megan Dunn is a Snohomish County Council member, representing District 2. She lives in Everett.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Sunday, Dec. 21

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

A state Climate Commmitment Act map shows projects funded by the act's carbon auctions.
Editorial: Climate Commitment Act a two-fer for Washington

Its emissions auctions put price on carbon and use that revenue for climate investments.

Trump’s immigration policy based on race

After graduating from Snohomish High School and then the UW I joined… Continue reading

Medical freedom should be a right

The undercutting of public health has been going on for decades from… Continue reading

Book on Western Arctic shows what could be lost to drilling, mining

In his book “Wilderness and the American Mind” Roderick Nash asserts that… Continue reading

Paramount Pictures
George Bailey (Jimmy Stewart, center) is consoled by Mr. Martini after believing $8,000 of his company's money has been lost.
Comment: Welcome to Pottersville, U.S.A.; Population: us

There are disturbing parallels between our times and that of the dystopian town in ‘It’s a Wonderful Life.’

Comment: State funding cuts would devastate long-term care

The Legislature should at least maintain Medicaid funding for nursing facilities at current levels.

Water from the Snohomish River surrounds a residence along the west side of Lowell Snohomish River Road on Thursday, Dec. 11, 2025 in Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Keep eye on weather and on FEMA’s future

Recent flooding should give pause to those who believe federal disaster aid is unnecessary.

Comment: No trust due an administration that ended river pact

The White House killed a negotiated deal to save salmon. The rivers’ protectors must return to court.

Comment: $20-an-hour pay for fast food workers will kill jobs

To protect employment, other states should avoid adopting California’s 2024 wage law.

Charles Adkins
Forum: To make investments we need, wealthy can pay fair share

As state lawmakers consider budgets, they should reconsider proposals for more progressive taxes.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, Dec. 19

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.