Commentary: Oil trains need big enough crew for safety

Legislation would ensure trains carrying hazardous materials have workers ready if a problem arises.

By Derek Stanford and Mike Sells / For The Herald

Anyone who lives in Snohomish County can tell train traffic is increasing.

More passenger trains are running to and from Seattle, serving commuters and baseball fans alike. More freight trains are running goods from the Port of Everett to British Columbia, and more oil trains are passing through our region on the way to refineries along the coast.

These are all welcome indicators of economic development, but one of them brings with it a potential threat to public safety.

The shale oil boom in the Bakken oil fields, in North Dakota and eastern Montana, has exploded oil train traffic across Washington. More than 1 million barrels of oil are shipped through our state each year, and the trains that carry them are getting longer; many now stretch more than a mile. Yet as more trains pass through the area, safety regulations have not kept up.

Washington used to impose minimum requirements for train crew sizes, ensuring more hands and eyes were available to help move the train to its destination safely, to prevent or mitigate breakdowns, or to serve as first responders in the event of an accident involving their train. But those minimums were removed in 1966, and train crews have been steadily shrinking ever since, even though the freight they move has become more volatile.

Some rail industry leaders have even expressed a desire to eliminate crews entirely, relying solely on technology to operate trains; even those with more than 100 tanker cars of hazardous materials traveling up to 60 miles per hour. Commercial planes flown in the United States are required to have co-pilots and additional flight crew members based on the nature of the flight route and cargo. Shouldn’t we require similar safety measures on trains carrying highly combustible materials through our communities?

The length of these trains constitutes a growing challenge for their operators; the longer the train, the more cars that are beyond the crew’s line of sight. If the rear portion of a train catches fire, which is known to happen, it’s possible an engineer or conductor positioned on the opposite side of the locomotive cab might not even be able to see it. In addition to carrying greater risks, the growing length of trains slows down response time and costs valuable minutes in an emergency. In 2016, an oil train heading to a refinery in Tacoma derailed and caught fire in the Columbia River Gorge. The town of Mosier, Oregon, was evacuated and cleanup continues to this day.

Fortunately, some basic common-sense steps would improve public safety regulations for the freight rail industry. HB 1841 and SB 5877, cosponsored by bipartisan legislators in both chambers including many from Snohomish County, would set minimum standards for multiple-person train crews on trains carrying hazardous materials. HB 1841 passed the House Jan. 30 and is scheduled for a public hearing in the Senate Labor & Commerce Committee on Feb. 20. It provides a simple but effective way to put well-trained people on freight trains before an accident occurs. It makes public safety a priority, and it catches our state up to the real-world risks of train traffic today — something that is long overdue.

This is a public safety imperative that must not wait any longer.

State Sen. Derek Sanford, D-Bothell, represents the 1st Legislative District. State Rep. Mike Sells, D-Everett, represents the 38th Legislative District.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Sunday, Jan. 5

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Artist Natalie Niblack works amongst her project entitled “33 Birds / Three Degrees” during the setup for Exploring The Edge at Schack Art Center on Sunday, March 19, 2023, in Everett, Washington. The paintings feature motion-activated speakers that play each bird’s unique call. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Editorial: An opinionated look back at 2024’s Herald editorials

Among highlights and lowlights: Boeing’s struggles, light rail’s arrival and the return of orcas.

-- PHOTO MOVED IN ADVANCE AND NOT FOR USE - ONLINE OR IN PRINT - BEFORE MARCH 06, 2016. -- Bob Dylan in New York in 1963. The musician’s private trove, which had been little more than a rumor, has been acquired for an estimated $15 million to $20 million. (William C. Eckenberg/The New York Times)
Comment: The ever-changin’ Bob Dylan

Dylan’s refusal to be pigeon-holed inspired other musicians and transformed rock music’s future.

New Year’s resolutions for The Herald

New Year’s Resolutions 2025 goals for The Herald Suggested New Year resolutions… Continue reading

Please list TV sports schedule in The Herald again

Herald Sports Please list TV schedule again When The Herald first started… Continue reading

Eco-Nomics: Looking back and forward on the climate crisis

2024 saw a mix of good and bad climate news. This year offers a chance to tip the scales in our favor.

Forum: Kept or not, making resolutions is a helpful process

The effort offers a chance to reflect on your time, your word, your attention and your connections.

Forum: Finding acceptance, rather than shame in missing mark

When hopes for a personal goal fall short, we can choose guilt or accept the grace of learning from it.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Thursday, Jan. 2

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Stethoscope, glasses and calculator on financial documents close up.
Editorial: Follow through on promise of medical price clarity

Hospitals aren’t fully complying with laws on price transparency, including three in Snohomish County.

A person vaping in New York, July 7, 2024. Millions of Americans use e-cigarettes — there’s little research into how to help them stop. (Justin J Wee/The New York Times)
Editorial: Protect state’s youths from flavored vapes, tobacco

With federal regulation likely ending, the state should bar an addictive, dangerous product.

Everett AquaSox infielder Michael Arroyo, the Seattle Mariners' 12th-ranked prospect, catches a baseball prior to Everett's game against the Eugene Emeralds on August 3, 2024, at Funko Field in Everett, Washington. (Photo courtesy of Evan Morud, Everett AquaSox)
Editorial: ‘Small ball’ by council can advance Everett stadium

A fiscal ‘game plan’ shows how the city can build a downtown stadium for baseball and soccer.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.