Schwab: Difference between Trump and other GOP presidents?

Others may have sought similar policies, but who gives a thumbs-up posing with a newly orphaned child?

By Sid Schwab

Herald columnist

Last week, Trump’s toxicity flared like that exploded Russian missile. And here’s the thing: Any Republican president would have given them what Trump did. Ttax cuts, deregulation (perhaps not all would have re-allowed carcinogens, made global warming worse, or set about killing Bristol Bay); maybe even reneged on the Iran and Paris agreements. For sure, lying that Democrats want socialism.

Some reasonable people might support Trump because of those actions, even as it requires disowning former outrage at budget deficits, abandoning arguments for free markets, and acquiescing to poisonous levels of xeno-, homo- and Islamophobia.

But there’s a mammoth difference between Trump and any theoretical Republican president, not to mention most human beings: his adamantine indecency and inhumanity. Some called it “presidential” when he stood against murder in his “unity” speech. Anyone paying attention, though, knew he’d revert to type in less than a day. He did.

Even if he weren’t a racist (he is); even if his divisive, hate-promoting language weren’t intentionally divisive and hate-promoting (it is), the peril of Trump is obvious. Doesn’t matter how great the economy is, even if it’s because he hasn’t ended what President Obama began (it is, and he’s about to, and it’ll be on him); doesn’t matter that unemployment is low, even if it’s because he hasn’t ended what President Obama began (it is, and he will). Trump’s pathological need for adulation, for which he’ll do and say anything and which we witnessed in high relief last week, threatens all Americans; even those thanking Jesus for purging voter rolls and hiring Vladimir Putin to put him in office.

After those murders, Trump’s psychopathy was writ large, showcasing his doleful inability to act as normal people behave toward one another. Because he can’t help it, he made his trips to El Paso and Dayton entirely about himself. Inappropriate crowd-size brags. Preferring to attack opponents instead of consoling a grieving nation. Calling a discharged patient back to pose with him because other victims refused. Demanding aides say he was received like a “rock star.”

Which is the key to understanding Trump: his overarching need to be treated like a rock star. In a “president,” for its exploitability, it’s ominous. Kim, Putin, MBS and Xi are using it to their advantage.

Then, that grotesque photo-op: Melania, smiling like a bridesmaid, holding a baby orphaned by a mass murderer who’d manifestoed all the hateful words Trump disgorges at every rally. Trump giving a bizarre thumbs-up, s-e grin plastered on his face like a fresco in the Ninth Circle.

Hours after his perfunctory visitations came the ICE raid in Mississippi. Nearly 700 people, herded into buses, many of whom were there legally. Children and parents traumatized, some still separated days later. To whose benefit? Contrary to Trump’s anti-immigrant demagoguery, these people, legal or not, were working, paying taxes. Illegal is illegal, but is this the best use of ICE’s resources? And what of the owners (who just happened to owe those workers millions); like TrumpCo, off the hook if they didn’t “knowingly,” wink, wink, hire the undocumented. Let’s see how the factory does without them. Let’s see how many “real” Americans apply for those jobs.

Accomplishing little else for America, such raids are intended to please the most rabid Trumpists. Another key to understanding Trump: appeal to the worst in the most misguided, for it’s they who give him the fawning blandishment he craves. No policy homework required.

Topping it off, the “president” of the United States, role model, retweeted a claim that the Clintons were behind Trump party-pal Jeffery Epstein’s death. If Trump can do that, which some might consider legerdemain, let the rest of us consider whose DOJ took him off suicide watch and mysteriously removed his cellmate. And whose AG will investigate.

Trump’s divisiveness is what renders unto him the veneration he requires, no matter the damage it causes. A third of the country loves it. Like Trump, they see the dysfunction and fracturing it has engendered as affirmatory. But for Republicans who care — surely they exist — demanding better of themselves and their party is overdue. Including selecting a more worthy standard-bearer.

World problems are gathering faster than glaciers are melting: Hong Kong, Kashmir, Syria, Iran, tariff-ruined farmers, looming recession, the accelerating climate crisis. Trump’s toolbox contains only false promises, ignorant narcissism, lying, tweeting and caving to dictators. In a role once considered leadership of the free world, that’s not enough.

Conservatives used to be better than this. We all did.

Email Sid Schwab at columnsid@gmail.com.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Monday, Dec. 16

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

FILE — Jet fuselages at Boeing’s fabrication site in Everett, Wash., Sept. 28, 2022. Some recently manufactured Boeing and Airbus jets have components made from titanium that was sold using fake documentation verifying the material’s authenticity, according to a supplier for the plane makers. (Jovelle Tamayo/The New York Times)
Editorial: A trade-dependent state braces for Trump’s tariffs

The leader of a state trade council is wary of the president-elect’s talk of tariffs and trade wars.

What are limits of rights, restrictions for guns?

Like Will Rogers, all I know is what I read in the… Continue reading

Why pay for garbage collection when it’s not collected?

I have noticed that every time there is inclement weather or a… Continue reading

Herald should allow reporters time to research

I understand the need to create benchmarks and goals for employees. But… Continue reading

Reform of state taxes needed to meet needs

As a retired Northshore English teacher and current director of a small… Continue reading

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, Dec. 13

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Free Application for Federal Student Aid FAFSA is shown on a photo using the text (Getty Images)
Editorial: Applying for financial aid key for students, economy

As families risk leaving money on the table, the state risks leaving well-paid jobs unfilled.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Sunday, Dec. 15

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

CITYPARK, which will be renamed Energizer Park in 2025, is the home of St. Louis' Major League Soccer club CITY SC. The stadium seats 22,423 and sold out 34 home games in a row last season. (CITY SC)
Comment: How to build a stadium and keep taxpayers happy

St. Louis’ MLS stadium, CITYPARK, offers four lessons for communities considering sports arenas.

Comment: Our public health system needs preventive medicine

Politics and short-sighted budget cuts threaten the nation’s public health system. It needs your voice.

Comment: Push for broadband for all will require all players

A federal grant provides much of what the state needs, but there’s work ahead to make it count.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.