Even after ‘ultimate flush-it game,’ M’s offense issues linger

The Mariners’ offensive woes beg the question as to whether lineup changes are needed.

  • Mike Vorel, The Seattle Times
  • Friday, May 10, 2024 3:30pm
  • SportsMariners

Play-by-play man Aaron Goldsmith dubbed it “the ultimate flush-it game.”

Which is an apropos descriptor for the Mariners’ morose matinee, an 11-1 loss to the Minnesota Twins at Target Field on Thursday. The thud snapped Seattle’s streak of six consecutive series wins, as the Mariners dropped three of four to a stampeding Twins team that had won 15 of their past 17 games.

This was a comprehensively dispiriting dud — complete with 15 Mariner strikeouts; a five-run Twins first inning against stalwart starter Logan Gilbert; six scattered Mariner hits; two errors; and a Mitch Garver liner that ricocheted off the glove of third baseman Jose Miranda, turned right and fell flukily into shortstop Willi Castro’s waiting mitt.

It was that kind of day.

Even so, unsightly losses in a six-month baseball season are inevitable, particularly those against a surging opponent punctuating a seven-game road trip. Alone, it’s a pothole on the interstate, not the edge of a gaping cliff.

This pothole, perhaps, can be flushed, forgotten, learned from.

But concerning questions linger.

Namely: Is it nearing time to tinker with the lineup card to infuse offense?

Yes, this lineup whiffs at an alarming rate, leading the majors through Thursday in both total strikeouts (399) and strikeout percentage (28.3%). That weakness was mercilessly exposed in Minnesota, as the Mariners struck out 53 times (13.3 times per game) in a four-game set, against a Twins staff that tops MLB in strikeouts per nine innings (10.2) and strikeout rate (27.0%).

For the Mariners, this was a bad matchup. But it’s also a pervasive problem. Look down the lineup, and Cal Raleigh (33.6%), Luke Raley (31.9%), Jorge Polanco (31.2%), Mitch Garver (30.7%), Luis Urias (30.4%), Mitch Haniger (30.2%), Dylan Moore (28.4%), Julio Rodriguez (28%) and Ty France (24.8%) all owned a strikeout rate above the MLB average (22.5%).

Through 38 games, Josh Rojas is an outlier, in more ways than one.

The 29-year-old third baseman was striking out at a 17.8% clip, while also doing damage — batting .348 with a .420 on-base percentage, three homers, eight RBI and 12 runs in 28 games. But Rojas (a left-handed hitter) continues to operate in a time share with Urias at third, generally sitting against left-handed starters while moonlighting in left field as well.

Regardless of position, Rojas has earned a more regular role. His career splits against lefties are also far from catastrophe — a .253 average, .332 on-base percentage, six homers and 32 RBI in 404 plate appearances.

Point being: The Mariners must find a way to highlight their hottest hitters.

Raley being one.

In his last 10 games, the 6-foot-4, 235-pounder is 9 for 24 (.375) with a homer and three RBI. To date, the former Tampa Bay Ray has appeared in 10 games in left field, nine games in right field, four games at first base and one in center. And though he may not be a long-term answer, it’s worth wondering if Raley — who hit 19 homers in 118 games in 2023 — could provide a change of pace for the slumping France (1B) or Haniger (RF).

The aforementioned France, of course, has yet to regain his all-star form from the first half of 2022.

2022 second half (61 games): .229/.287/.390, 9 HR, 34 RBI.

2023 (158 games): .250/.337/.366, 12 HR, 58 RBI, 0.7 WAR.

2024 (34 games): .240/.301/.331, 2 HR, 9 RBI, -0.5 WAR.

Those aren’t the splits of a premium run-producer. Moreover, France’s strikeout rate (24.8%) represents a significant spike from 2023 (17.6%), 2022 (15.3%) and 2021 (16.3%). He also hit into 25 double plays last season (second in MLB), and is on pace to hit into 24 more in 2024. And in his past 10 games France was 7-for-40 (.175) with zero homers, one RBI, two walks and 14 strikeouts.

Haniger, likewise, is mired in an extended slump. The 33-year-old hadn’t had more than one hit in a game since April 16. In the ensuing 18 games he was 9-for-67 (.134) with two homers, three walks, eight RBI and 25 strikeouts. And his strikeout rate, 30.2%, would be the highest of his career.

Which is where we acknowledge that it’s relatively early. These are established veterans, and the only way to regain a rhythm is to receive regular at-bats. The most practical plan might, in fact, be a staying of the collective course — a consistent lineup card, a continued faith in France and Haniger to find their form.

But sooner or later, they have to hit. The Mariners’ rotation finally hit a momentary hiccup, after ripping off 21 consecutive starts of two runs or fewer (the longest stretch in MLB since 1917). In their last five games, Bryce Miller (4 ER in 6+ innings), Luis Castillo (3 ER in 6 2/3 innings), Emerson Hancock (4 ER in 4 innings), George Kirby (4 ER in 5 innings) and Gilbert (8 ER in 4 innings) returned to Earth. Meanwhile, an injury to trusted lefty Tayler Saucedo further strained the depth of an already embattled bullpen.

The Mariners will attempt to flush Thursday’s loss — and a three-game home set against the Oakland Athletics (18-21) is a good way to do it. That’s followed by 10 games against the formidable Kansas City Royals (22-16), Baltimore Orioles (24-12) and New York Yankees (25-14).

Likewise, there’s time for Seattle’s assortment of sputtering vets — France, Haniger, Garver, Polanco, etc. — to flush the past and move forward.

But even in May, these games all matter.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Stanwood sophomore Tanner Requa tags out the lead runner after getting him in a pickle during a playoff loss to Kentlake on Tuesday, May 14, 2024, at Kent Meridian High School in Kent, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Prep baseball roundup for Friday, April 4

Tanner Requa’s no-hitter pushes Stanwood to 8-0.

Prep girls tennis roundup for Friday, April 4

Jackson improves to 4-0 in league play with 5-2 win.

Prep softball roundup for Friday, April 4

Sarah Fletcher hits three homers, scores five times as Murphy wins 17-7.

Cam Hiatt is The Herald's 2024-2025 Boys Basketball Player of the Year. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Cam Hiatt is The Herald’s 2024-25 Boys Basketball Player of the Year

In a homecoming season, the Wesco 3A South MVP led Edmonds-Woodway to the state final.

The Herald’s 2024-25 All-Area boys basketball team

Editor’s note: The Player of the Year and All-Area team were chosen… Continue reading

Arlington’s Leyton Martin puts three fingers in the air after making a three point shot during the game against Glacier Peak on Friday, Jan. 17, 2025 in Arlington, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Martin, Palocol, Hiatt named Wesco boys basketball MVPs

Glacier Peak puts three players on the Wesco 4A all-league team.

Prep roundup for Thursday, April 3

Freshman Aliana Langsea delivers for Jackson softball.

Vikings quarterback Sam Darnold, right, greets Seahawks quarterback Geno Smith after Minnesota's win in Seattle on Dec. 22, 2025. (Anthony Souffle / The Minnesota Star Tribune / Tribune News Services)
Geno Smith’s new deal indicates he wanted out of Seattle.

Maybe he just didn’t want to be here, after all. Geno Smith… Continue reading

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for March 23-29

The Athlete of the Week nominees for March 23-29. Voting closes at… Continue reading

Everett Silvertips’ Carter Bear on Wednesday, Jan. 29, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Tips drop Game 3 against Seattle, Bear earns WHL honor

Everett blows 2-goal lead to lose 6-3, trails 2-1 in series; injured forward makes 2nd Team.

Jackson’s Drew Pepin yells after striking out the final batter to end the game against Edmonds-Woodway on Wednesday, April 2, 2025 in Edmonds, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Prep baseball roundup for Wednesday, April 2

Jackson’s Pepin pitches ‘gem’ against E-W.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.